The closest you could get (with any semblance of honesty) is claiming there is too much error to determine if Earth is stationary.Exactly the point of my previous message: the RE now have to deal with the fact that a few of the readings DO INDEED prove that the Earth is stationary.
You cannot claim too much error: any argument brought in the debate, whatever it is (temperature, equipment), can be turned immediately against the RE.
You have to deal with the fact that the readings, several of them, showed NO ROTATION AT ALL.
So, as far as the MGX goes, if the FE do not want to get involved in very long debates, all they have to do is point out that the MGX registered several readings with no rotation at all.
However, the RE will now bring the RING LASER GYROSCOPES into play, both terrestrial and used in airplanes, with a much higher degree of accuracy, to claim the Earth is rotating. Seismic waves, Earth's line fluctuations can be explained by the RE, so that eventually the FE will need my formula to claim victory.
There is nothing wrong with my formula: it is splendidly correct.
A second reference which confirms my global/generalized Sagnac effect formula.
https://apps.dtic.mil/dtic/tr/fulltext/u2/a206219.pdfStudies of phase-conjugate optical devices concepts
US OF NAVAL RESEARCH, Physics Division
Dr. P. Yeh
PhD, Caltech, Nonlinear Optics
Principal Scientist of the Optics Department at Rockwell International Science Center
Professor, UCSB
"Engineer of the Year," at Rockwell Science Center
Leonardo da Vinci Award in 1985
Fellow of the Optical Society of America, the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers
page 152 of the pdf document, section Recent Advances in Photorefractive Nonlinear Optics page 4
The MPPC acts like a normal mirror and Sagnac interferometry is obtained. Phase-Conjugate Multimode Fiber Gyro
Published in the Journal of Optics Letters, vol. 12, page 1023, 1987
page 69 of the pdf document, page 1 of the article
A second confirmation of the fact that my formula is correct.
Here is the first confirmation:
Self-pumped phase-conjugate fiber-optic gyro, I. McMichael, P. Yeh, Optics Letters 11(10):686-8 · November 1986
http://www.dtic.mil/dtic/tr/fulltext/u2/a170203.pdf (appendix 5.1)
Exactly the formula obtained by Professor Yeh:
φ = -2(φ
2 - φ
1) = 4π(R
1L
1 + R
2L
2)Ω/λc = 4π(V
1L
1 + V
2L
2)/λc
Since Δφ = 2πc/λ x Δt, Δt = 2(R1L1 + R2L2)Ω/c2 = 2(V1L1 + V2L2)/c2CORRECT SAGNAC FORMULA:
2(V1L1 + V2L2)/c2The very same formula obtained for a Sagnac interferometer which features two different lengths and two different velocities.
http://www.dtic.mil/dtic/tr/fulltext/u2/a170203.pdfANNUAL TECHNICAL REPORT PREPARED FOR THE US OF NAVAL RESEARCH.
Page 18 of the pdf document, Section 3.0 Progress:
Our first objective was to demonstrate that the phase-conjugate fiberoptic gyro (PCFOG) described in Section 2.3 is sensitive to rotation. This phase shift plays an important role in the detection of the Sagnac phase shift due to rotation. Page 38 of the pdf document, page 6 of Appendix 3.1
it does demonstrate the measurement of the Sagnac phase shift Eq. (3)HERE IS EQUATION (3) OF THE PAPER, PAGE 3 OF APPENDIX 3.1:
φ = -2(φ
2 - φ
1) = 4π(R
1L
1 + R
2L
2)Ω/λc = 4π(V
1L
1 + V
2L
2)/λc
Since Δφ = 2πc/λ x Δt, Δt = 2(R1L1 + R2L2)Ω/c2 = 2(V1L1 + V2L2)/c2CORRECT SAGNAC FORMULA:
2(V1L1 + V2L2)/c2