The game rules recommend rock paper scissors in case of disagreement.
Because bullwinkle is inactive at any time (not game day), there is a 50% chance of dying. A representative from both teams will decide whether bullwinkle will survive tomorrow. the elected representatives are space cowgirl and boydster, the first to die from both teams.
I will send a pm to both players and ask them to say rock paper and scissors. If boydster wins, bullwinkle will die tomorrow, if space cowgirl wins, bullwinkle will survive tomorrow. this selection has nothing to do with the team that bullwinkle belongs to, it was chosen completely at random.