With Shifter, Crouton, Ichi, and Duck (supposedly) dead, the presumed Roundy The Truthinessist declared this The Darkest Timeline. He proposed to the remaining villagers that they become the Werepenguin Destructors and to find a way to the "Prime Timeline" that began in Ben Lawers and spawned this terrible reality they were now stuck in. Once there, they would kill their counterparts and take over their lives. He handed them all black beards made out of felt to symbolize their team spirit, but only Bullwinkle agreed to wear it.
BUT. Roundy The Truthinessist had previously appeared to his duplicate, Roundy2.0, when he had been separated from the TFES.org site and was forced to re-enroll in the the Flat Earth Society's ranks once more. Desperate to cope with the very recent loss of his best friend DuckDodgers, Roundy The Truthinessist turned to his alter-ego Roundy2.0 for help, agreeing to undergo a goatee transplant with him. Unfortunately, Roundy2.0 persuades Roundy The Truthinessist into re-entering TFES.org, leaving only Roundy2.0 (posing as Roundy The Truthinessist) to convince the villagers of his innocence.
There was one problem. Roundy2.0 was not committed to his character impersonation in the least. Space Cowgirl tried to stick s'mores to his body, and he peeled them off as fast as she could apply them. Bullwinkle tried to joke with him about the giant laser hole that spanned the entire plane, only to have Evil Roundy (Roundy2.0's pet name for himself) flip him off and, awkwardly, moon him while only standing inches away. Even Shifter's ghost attempted to lighten the mood, promising not to fling mind-serum-tipped kangaroo finger bones at Roundy. And Evil Roundy just stared at him, blankly.
So, the time had come. Evil Roundy, having utterly failed at creating a sufficient number of allies within the Villager camp, was marched to the rope from which he would hang, with those around him thinking he was Roundy The Truthinessist the entire time. Sure, they wondered what had become of him, when he had turned so cold, why he was the way that he suddenly was. But that didn't matter. He would hang, and the questions would be gone.
Evil Roundy stood in front of his accusers, rope tightened around his neck, and said to them: "AAAAH-HAHAHAHAHA I'M EVIL ROUNDY, YOU MOFOS!"
The platform below his feet fell. His body dropped and went limp. Roundy2.0, imposter for Roundy The Truthinessist, was dead. And with Evil Roundy's death, The True Roundy The Truthinessist found himself in an interdimensional limbo. Not able to physically join his companions by day, but able to speak with them through the ethereal plane by night.
Roundy The Truthiness, a normal villager, walked no more among the plane of the living.