Werepenguins - The Perth Massacre

Actually I'd say penguins are closer to knowing who it is than the rest. penguins actually know the affiliation of one more person other than themselves, while the rest of us know no one.

I haven't much to go on, so I'm just going to throw out 2 names I think are penguins and see what happens. I think it's Jura and Sir Cruton.

If I was a penguin, it would make much more sense for me to advocate to lynch or kill people whom others think are innocent.  They are the competition as one less vote for them is a more likely vote for the penguins.  I would also advocate to lynch people that I feel are on my tracks, or, I could advocate to lynch random people, like SCG and Jane did in order to throw everyone against each other. 

I don't know, and feel bad about speculating.

What the F am I saying here?  I reread it and it does not make any sense.  You people can lynch me, if you want.  I can't even type a cohesive paragraph, and I am neither a penguin, nor a psychic or exorcist, so a vote for me is not a vote against the good guys.  What am I even saying? 

Actually I'd say penguins are closer to knowing who it is than the rest. penguins actually know the affiliation of one more person other than themselves, while the rest of us know no one.

No, the rest of us, non-collectively, know two.  The bad guys collectively know two, minus one. 

Maybe I'm wrong, but this seems a bit like a reverse psychology trick from jroa. He asks to be lynched so that we won't do it. But then again he also did that in last game. I'm so confused 

Quote from: Pezevenk on July 30, 2018, 06:18:23 AM

Actually I'd say penguins are closer to knowing who it is than the rest. penguins actually know the affiliation of one more person other than themselves, while the rest of us know no one.

No, the rest of us, non-collectively, know two.  The bad guys collectively know two, minus one.

Ah... That makes even less sense.

...What am I even saying?

Huh.  Sounds almost like something that someone with two disparate entities inhabiting the same body would say...

Is this guilt, coming to the fore?  Or an innocent man trying to protect himself with reverse psychology?

Just lynch me.  If you believe that I don't usually lie, then you will believe that I am not anything.  If you think I lie, then there is a suspicion that I am a penguin and need to be taken out anyway.  Either way, an innocent person won't die.

I will die knowing, at the least, that boydster is not a penguin.  Sorry for jumping your ass last time, bro. 

Please stop confusing me further. I'm confused enough as it is.

How many people here can think of a time when I lied to them about anything?  Please put your hands in the air. 

I suggest we take the same caution as last time: don't vote until we have a consensus. We don't want to waste a vote. Current suspects seem to be:

Roundy - Was first to vote with limited information, defensive, only one who'd get anything from Ichi's death
SCG - is good at being a penguin, keeping a low profile,
Me - is good at being a penguin,
Jura - Advocates for inaction, could be playing us,
jroa - is just generally suspicious
Bullwinkle - would have been a good choice to be killed if penguins were trying to dissuade, kept a low profile
deadsirius - reasons?
Crouton - also reasons

You know I'm wary of Roundy, but otherwise Bullwinkle and Jura seem suspected. And people just want to kill jroa, but what's new there?

Well, a vote for me is at the least not a vote to kill the exorcist or the scientist, or what ever he is called.  I am not a penguin, though.  But, if you blood thirst people want to kill someone, at leat you will not be killing someone important.

Also, I don't lie.

And people just want to kill jroa, but what's new there?

Eh, not really. It seems more like jroa wants to kill jroa for some reason. But again, this behaviour is very suspicious. I don't understand why he's doing this.

Have I ever lied to you, even once? 

I will pour a drink out for our lost brothers.  Frankly I suspected ichimaru (not sure why...I just did for some reason).  Wrong again.

Anyway, I figure it's about time to get myself on the radar a bit.  One thing I've learned in my studies of werepenguin behavior is that they tend to pick off the least suspected party members first, allowing the more suspicious to destroy each other in the meantime.  Since no one has yet mentioned me, I'm beginning to feel like a prime target for the penguins.

Here's my thoughts at the moment:

Jane/SCG:  the only ones with a proven track record as penguins.  They ran the board last time and know what they're doing.  Highly improbable that it would be both of them again, but I wouldn't rule out one of them.

Jura:  Seems to be the only one advocating for inaction.  Honestly I can see the wisdom in this, but...it would be a brilliant piece of misdirection for a penguin watching its own hide...

Roundy:  Seems to have drawn suspicion, though I don't really know why.  His response does not encourage me, but for some reason I don't like choice.  Again, we all know what my instinct is worth though...

Pez:  as before, he seems like a possibility...but only just a possibility.  He's hard to read but I'm not quite ready to throw suspicion on him...yet.

Jroa:  suspicious to me...but maybe that's just the way he is.  I would probably support a movement to lynch, though admittedly not for any great reason.

DuckDodgers:  I think it's quite likely he's either the truthterra...or a penguin.  This would be a high risk/high reward type of choice, so I'm willing to go with the majority on this one.

Bullwinkle:  probably benign, but...maybe.

Crouton:  a little too innocent-seeming.  If the penguins don't take him early he will become suspect to me but not yet.

In short, to narrow it down by half, I could see going after jroa, DuckDodgers (risky), Jura, and Space Cowgirl or Jane (but not both).

Hopefully this makes me less of an obvious target for the devil birds...

I can't hold that against you.  Even on the best of days I'm a bit spheniscidaeish.

Have I ever lied to you, even once?

Now that you mention it, no, I don't remember you ever trying to pretend you were someone you weren't 

I don't understand how Ichi's death helps Roundy, other than it's seemingly random. It doesn't make him more or less suspicious because of it though.

Jroa seems to be pulling a quasi BHS move and throwing himself on the sword for no good reason. This could be a high level con to reverse psychology us out of killing him, but I'm more inclined to believe his innocence for the time being.

Yeah, really, I am nothing.  I just thought it would be funny to confuse people with unintelligible shit.  I have a few suspicions, but I don't want to point fingers as I was so wrong last time. 

Or am I?

ftp://

Or am I?

Maybe he's just drunk.  This is a pub after all

 Jura despondently orders another malt, since issuing the proclamation (https://www.theflatearthsociety.org/forum/index.php?topic=77046.msg2082606#msg2082606) which he thought was the answer, brilliant a stroke of fucking genius, not only had he (FFS read it) been touted as enemy, but Jroa, roundy, Ducks, SCG, Jane, Crout’ and Bully had all had the finger pointed at them, this has all the hallmarks of FUBAR.

Two people have me on their hitlist, Jane & Ducky, does that make them feathered in the night-time or feathered in the brain? If trying to protect the prophet with our bodies while he/she investigates, doesn’t seem a worthy alternative to blindly lashing about, then I’m stumped.

And I singularly do not see how this helps the penguins, please explain?

ftp://

Quote from: jroa on July 30, 2018, 07:04:54 AM

Or am I?

Maybe he's just drunk.  This is a pub after all

I will go with this one.

He is definitely just a junkard. 

He is. 

 Jura despondently orders another malt

Okay this is probably a trivial point but who is serving the drinks?

Is it one of us?

Is it boydster?

I am going to come clean.  JRowe = Jura = jroa.  Are you people happy now? 

Big mouth, I'm never talking to me again.

I forgot to add Junker.

I am going to come clean.  JRowe = Jura = jroa.  Are you people happy now?

Wtf is going on? I feel like we are only getting half of a conversation here.

Quote from: Jura-Glenlivet II on July 30, 2018, 07:10:12 AM

 Jura despondently orders another malt

Okay this is probably a trivial point but who is serving the drinks?

Is it one of us?

Is it boydster?

Groundskeeper Willy.

Quote from: jroa on July 30, 2018, 07:19:48 AM

I am going to come clean.  JRowe = Jura = jroa.  Are you people happy now?

Wtf is going on? I feel like we are only getting half of a conversation here.

Or, am I?

I will admit that I lied at least once, as far as I know, in this thread.  I will not lie again.  Sorry.