I'll be the first to admit, I'm not in a place where I'm completely happy with my carnitas yet. But they did come out passable. This was my first attempt, so I found
this recipe here and made it basically exactly as written.
Some notes:
- You can hold back on the cumin a bit, a tablespoon was a bit heavy-handed. I mean, if you grew up having tacos made with Old El Paso taco seasoning, you'll be right at home, but it's really too much
- Between the coke, OJ, and lime juice, it's a lot of sugar. That's not necessarily a bad thing, but it's a flavor you need to plan ahead for and balance out, because the recipe I linked before does not balance it out particularly well. Especially if you made the decision to reduce the liquids left over after you shred the pork and use those liquids as a way to boost the flavor.
- Get the Mexican oregano if you can. I didn't. It was obvious. There's a clear difference between "regular" oregano and Mexican oregano.
Next time I make this, I'm going to replace some of the liquids with lard so it's a bit more traditional. I'm also going heavier on the garlic and herbs. And heat. It needs a little bit of heat. I added some cayenne, not enough though, and I think some jalapeno would be better. And I'm swapping the pepper out for white pepper next time for sure.
Last thing: Don't skip the crisping step. Spread the shredded pork out on a baking sheet and get the broiler ripping, then let it crisp up for a few minutes.