Stars shouldn't even register as pixels or the smallest things humans can see, they shouldn't register at all, because of their comparative smallness with space, just as an amoeba doesn't register to the naked eye.
You still mix up just light and object which does not emit light. If amoeba would emit very bright light then we see this light even when we don't see amoeba. And we can see it in dark and quite a far away. Light moves, you know.
It seems so obvious to us, but when your entire belief system is hanging on various facts you created, I suppose nothing is ever going to penetrate your brain