The creation of the flat earth.

You are asking us to guess, like scientists who make an educated guess about the formation of stars and galaxies.  I will tell you I don't know, and don't care to guess. 

Let me ask you a question.  What was before the big bang?

Scientists do guess.  Not a single scientist has watches a star be born, live out its life, and die.  Yet, they will tell you every detail about what happens.

Do you even understand what an educated guess is?

Quote from: jroa on April 15, 2014, 08:43:25 AM

Do you even understand what an educated guess is?

Yes but that is not what they do. It is like if a pilot needs fuel for his flight and gave an educated guess on how much he needs. Not good enough.

Quote from: Starman on April 15, 2014, 08:51:43 AM

Quote from: jroa on April 15, 2014, 08:43:25 AM

Do you even understand what an educated guess is?

Yes but that is not what they do. It is like if a pilot needs fuel for his flight and gave an educated guess on how much he needs. Not good enough.

Are you claiming that a pilot knows exactly, to the last drop, how much fuel he needs?

Scientists do guess.  Not a single scientist has watches a star be born, live out its life, and die.  Yet, they will tell you every detail about what happens.
[/quote

You're right, for a single star, we can't see all of those life cycles. But they can, and do make comparisons. between stars. For instance, we take our sun, in the grand scheme of things, a very average star, and we observe another star, that is relatively similar to ours (roughly the same mass, roughly the same temperature) but older, and we see how it dies. And we see it again, and again, and so we have a firm theory as to how stars of similar composition will die. Then we see another star die, and it's different. But the star was significantly different (larger, hotter), does that invalidate our initial findings? NO! it's a different type of death.

Consider this more down to earth example: You visit a cow farm, you see a cow being milked, day after day, but then she stops producing milk, and you see her put down. As you're all sad about a cow being killed, you see a new born calf in the barn. Is there anything to make you think that that calf is going to have a different fate than the one you just witnessed?

Quote from: Starman on April 15, 2014, 08:51:43 AM

Quote from: jroa on April 15, 2014, 08:43:25 AM

Do you even understand what an educated guess is?

Yes but that is not what they do. It is like if a pilot needs fuel for his flight and gave an educated guess on how much he needs. Not good enough.

Are you claiming that a pilot knows exactly, to the last drop, how much fuel he needs?

Quote from: jroa on April 15, 2014, 08:26:00 AM

Scientists do guess.  Not a single scientist has watches a star be born, live out its life, and die.  Yet, they will tell you every detail about what happens.
[/quote

You're right, for a single star, we can't see all of those life cycles. But they can, and do make comparisons. between stars. For instance, we take our sun, in the grand scheme of things, a very average star, and we observe another star, that is relatively similar to ours (roughly the same mass, roughly the same temperature) but older, and we see how it dies. And we see it again, and again, and so we have a firm theory as to how stars of similar composition will die. Then we see another star die, and it's different. But the star was significantly different (larger, hotter), does that invalidate our initial findings? NO! it's a different type of death.

Consider this more down to earth example: You visit a cow farm, you see a cow being milked, day after day, but then she stops producing milk, and you see her put down. As you're all sad about a cow being killed, you see a new born calf in the barn. Is there anything to make you think that that calf is going to have a different fate than the one you just witnessed?

Wow, it is really confusing when you can not quote correctly. 

Quote from: RandomREalist on April 15, 2014, 09:48:35 AM

Quote from: jroa on April 15, 2014, 08:26:00 AM

Scientists do guess.  Not a single scientist has watches a star be born, live out its life, and die.  Yet, they will tell you every detail about what happens.
[/quote

You're right, for a single star, we can't see all of those life cycles. But they can, and do make comparisons. between stars. For instance, we take our sun, in the grand scheme of things, a very average star, and we observe another star, that is relatively similar to ours (roughly the same mass, roughly the same temperature) but older, and we see how it dies. And we see it again, and again, and so we have a firm theory as to how stars of similar composition will die. Then we see another star die, and it's different. But the star was significantly different (larger, hotter), does that invalidate our initial findings? NO! it's a different type of death.

Consider this more down to earth example: You visit a cow farm, you see a cow being milked, day after day, but then she stops producing milk, and you see her put down. As you're all sad about a cow being killed, you see a new born calf in the barn. Is there anything to make you think that that calf is going to have a different fate than the one you just witnessed?

Wow, it is really confusing when you can not quote correctly.

Have you even bothered to look up Phlogiston?

I still do not see where you have discredited the theory.  Can you put it in your own words?

I still do not see where you have discredited the theory.  Can you put it in your own words?

Quote from: jroa on April 16, 2014, 10:27:52 AM

I still do not see where you have discredited the theory.  Can you put it in your own words?

Obsolete scientific theory

To make it simple most of RE'ers knows that the stars and planets are created from leftover matter and gasses ofter stars explode at their end of life.  It is an cycle that has being going on for billions of year. This has been accepted for a very long time. Now the same question come to mind to how did the flat earth get created. Has it always existed? Not likely. God maybe? I hope some FE'ers can give me a logical explanation. If you don't say do.

Quote from: Starman on April 14, 2014, 05:41:27 PM

To make it simple most of RE'ers knows that the stars and planets are created from leftover matter and gasses ofter stars explode at their end of life.  It is an cycle that has being going on for billions of year. This has been accepted for a very long time. Now the same question come to mind to how did the flat earth get created. Has it always existed? Not likely. God maybe? I hope some FE'ers can give me a logical explanation. If you don't say do.

No one has ever produced granite by cooling magma.

Quote from: th3rm0m3t3r0 on April 16, 2014, 12:38:41 PM

Quote from: Starman on April 14, 2014, 05:41:27 PM

To make it simple most of RE'ers knows that the stars and planets are created from leftover matter and gasses ofter stars explode at their end of life.  It is an cycle that has being going on for billions of year. This has been accepted for a very long time. Now the same question come to mind to how did the flat earth get created. Has it always existed? Not likely. God maybe? I hope some FE'ers can give me a logical explanation. If you don't say do.

No one has ever produced granite by cooling magma.

Here is what I found on granite:
Almost all granite is igneous (it solidified from a magma) and plutonic (it did so in a large, deeply buried body or pluton). The random arrangement of grains in granite—its lack of fabric—is evidence of its plutonic origin. Rock with the same composition as granite can form through long and intense metamorphism of sedimentary rocks. But that kind of rock has a strong fabric and is usually called granite gneiss.

For sure... I am still waiting for any FE'ers to tell me how their FE came about.

Quote from: Starman on April 16, 2014, 12:54:55 PM

For sure... I am still waiting for any FE'ers to tell me how their FE came about.

Why should we know?
How could we know?
I know just as little as you do when it comes to the great question, "Why is there something, rather than nothing?".

Quote from: th3rm0m3t3r0 on April 16, 2014, 01:09:27 PM

Quote from: Starman on April 16, 2014, 12:54:55 PM

For sure... I am still waiting for any FE'ers to tell me how their FE came about.

Why should we know?
How could we know?
I know just as little as you do when it comes to the great question, "Why is there something, rather than nothing?".

Why would you not want to know. Why bother having this site if you don't ask questions like this?
If you study and understand the laws of physics you will truly know and understand why.
Don't speak for me when you say "Why is there something, rather than nothing" I understand how everything fits and works perfectly in the RE world and so does every RE'ers. If you look very carefully at yourself and other FE'ers you have lots of unanswered questions. The common fact about FE'ers is that they look at big and small details as the same. If you don't know where your planet comes from that is a big detail and a big deal.

Quote from: Starman on April 17, 2014, 06:17:40 PM

Quote from: th3rm0m3t3r0 on April 16, 2014, 01:09:27 PM

Quote from: Starman on April 16, 2014, 12:54:55 PM

For sure... I am still waiting for any FE'ers to tell me how their FE came about.

Why should we know?
How could we know?
I know just as little as you do when it comes to the great question, "Why is there something, rather than nothing?".

Why would you not want to know. Why bother having this site if you don't ask questions like this?
If you study and understand the laws of physics you will truly know and understand why.
Don't speak for me when you say "Why is there something, rather than nothing" I understand how everything fits and works perfectly in the RE world and so does every RE'ers. If you look very carefully at yourself and other FE'ers you have lots of unanswered questions. The common fact about FE'ers is that they look at big and small details as the same. If you don't know where your planet comes from that is a big detail and a big deal.

You don't know for sure where your planet came from.
If you say otherwise, you are being willfully ignorant.
Anything you regard as fact as to the origins of Earth is just a well educated guess.

the universe has always been, hard for man to comprehend, but true.
but until the big bang, when all matter that existed pulled together, and created the Universal Accelerator.
This caused all the matter to scatter and accelerate at 9.8 m/sec away from the source. The heaviest objects remained  towards the the bottom, the Earth in its great disc, which protects itself from the full force of the UA. Which made life possible.
The lighter objects, like the sun, the moon, planets, and stars (which are very small compared to the Earth) are all above, and are not protected against the UA causing them to be spherical, and devoid of life.