Your "argument" was just a satirical response used to ridicule the simulated reality theory and rottingroom himself. If you think that's how a debate is handled then you need to think twice.
Also, your argument was based in religion. Religion is not scientific, has no supporting evidence, and cannot be proven or disproved.
The argument we are making is that: It's a possibility that a civilization could become advanced enough to make simulated reality. This is supported by the fact that the society that we live in has already created simulated reality (or tries to, look at game devs, check out oculus rift for example). Of course, our "simulated realities" are nothing compared to what we are theorizing, but it could happen given enough time. If that's the case, then we could be living in another society's simulated reality program right now and not even know it. Of course, like many have stated,
this is a thought experiment. The possibility is there, there's a whole
wikipedia article on the topic that explains it way better than I do, which I suggest you read if you're at all interested in this idea.
It's all very interesting if you're a curious and bright individual, which the troll persona that you have developed is not... but hey, that's a story for another day.