WEREWOLF - Players only!

Quote from: Saddam Hussein on January 07, 2010, 08:15:17 PM

Wilmore, will you be writing a brief piece of fiction for everyone who dies?  Because if you are, when (if) I'm killed, I demand to go down like a badass, destroying half my house with a shotgun during a long battle with the wolf.  Or something like that.  Either way, it's neat.

How are you going to operate a shotgun with your wolf claws?

Quote from: Raist on January 07, 2010, 08:15:52 PM

And if they weren't killed the very next round (the wolves would know whether he is a wolf or a villager) then he would obviously be a wolf. A wolf would instantly kill anyone claiming to be a psychic in an attempt to eliminate that advantage.

This is true if they claimed it publically. But they could message someone privately claiming to be the psychic, in an attempt to avoid being lynched. Heck, they could message all the villagers and claim to be the psychic.

They could only safely message the people they checked out the night before. This means on the first night they couldn't message anyone. On the second night they could message one person but have no actual information for that person. One the third night they could tell 2 people.

Psychics have no real advantage claiming to be a psychic. If they messaged someone they hadn't checked out first then they would be at risk, and werewolves have even less of a reason to admit it because it draws immediate attention to them.

Not to mention that there are probably plenty of people dropping misleading statements to imply that they are a wolf (for the lulz). I agree with Parsifal, although I maintain my belief that Wilmore is in fact the Alpha Wolf.

Hmmmm.  It is something to ponder but we probably are facing some wily wolves who would out smart the centrifuge/wolf separator.

I think we should wait, at least this turn. Killing people too hastily never turns out good.

They could only safely message the people they checked out the night before. This means on the first night they couldn't message anyone. On the second night they could message one person but have no actual information for that person. One the third night they could tell 2 people.

This is only true for the real psychic. A wolf, knowing who its fellow wolves are, could message as many people as it wanted to, pretending to be the psychic, and tell each of them that they were the only one being told about it. Of course, they run the risk of messaging the actual psychic, but who is the psychic gonna tell? They don't know who the other two wolves are, and they'd have a hard time convincing the majority to lynch the wolf who messaged them without explicitly revealing themselves as the psychic.

Quote from: Mrs. Peach on January 07, 2010, 10:39:56 PM

Hmmmm.  It is something to ponder but we probably are facing some wily wolves who would out smart the centrifuge/wolf separator.

I think we should wait, at least this turn. Killing people too hastily never turns out good.

Quote from: Raist on January 07, 2010, 10:40:59 PM

They could only safely message the people they checked out the night before. This means on the first night they couldn't message anyone. On the second night they could message one person but have no actual information for that person. One the third night they could tell 2 people.

This is only true for the real psychic. A wolf, knowing who its fellow wolves are, could message as many people as it wanted to, pretending to be the psychic, and tell each of them that they were the only one being told about it. Of course, they run the risk of messaging the actual psychic, but who is the psychic gonna tell? They don't know who the other two wolves are, and they'd have a hard time convincing the majority to lynch the wolf who messaged them without explicitly revealing themselves as the psychic.

They would have absolute evidence to lynch that person.

If they could post them pm it would show that this other person was the wolf. Here's the logic.

The person that pm'ed him is either the psychic, and knows he is not a wolf that is why he is giving him the information. A villager has no reason to reveal the psychic or have him lynched.

This means that either the person that was pm'ed is either try to frame the psychic because he is a wolf, or is in fact the psychic and telling the truth. The real psychic would not be pm'ing a wolf because he would have checked him out first.

tl;dr the wolf would not receive a pm from the psychic.

They would have absolute evidence to lynch that person.

If they could post them pm it would show that this other person was the wolf. Here's the logic.

The person that pm'ed him is either the psychic, and knows he is not a wolf that is why he is giving him the information. A villager has no reason to reveal the psychic or have him lynched.

This means that either the person that was pm'ed is either try to frame the psychic because he is a wolf, or is in fact the psychic and telling the truth. The real psychic would not be pm'ing a wolf because he would have checked him out first.

tl;dr the wolf would not receive a pm from the psychic.

Yes, and come night time one of the other wolves will kill the psychic. What a clever plan those wolves had, they got the one villager who could tell who the wolves are out of the way.

Quote from: Raist on January 07, 2010, 10:51:34 PM

They would have absolute evidence to lynch that person.

If they could post them pm it would show that this other person was the wolf. Here's the logic.

The person that pm'ed him is either the psychic, and knows he is not a wolf that is why he is giving him the information. A villager has no reason to reveal the psychic or have him lynched.

This means that either the person that was pm'ed is either try to frame the psychic because he is a wolf, or is in fact the psychic and telling the truth. The real psychic would not be pm'ing a wolf because he would have checked him out first.

tl;dr the wolf would not receive a pm from the psychic.

Yes, and come night time one of the other wolves will kill the psychic. What a clever plan those wolves had, they got the one villager who could tell who the wolves are out of the way.

Yes, but at the cost of 1/3 of the wolves. The psychic could also use this pm as evidence to substantiate his claim as psychic and kill any other wolves he has found out in the next few rounds because the villagers will believe him. He could also hold that pm until he has found another wolf.

Yes, but at the cost of 1/3 of the wolves. The psychic could also use this pm as evidence to substantiate his claim as psychic and kill any other wolves he has found out in the next few rounds because the villagers will believe him. He could also hold that pm until he has found another wolf.

And while he's holding that PM, the other 19 villagers think they know who the psychic is and listen to the information being fed to them.

I think I'll just wait till a bandwagon gets rolling and jump on.  Yup, mob mentality for me.

Can we just put them in the stocks instead?

I think I'll just wait till a bandwagon gets rolling and jump on.  Yup, mob mentality for me.

Same here, just to get the kill. It seems Parsifal has the highest amount of votes so far. Hmm...

Wait before we start lynching. As somebody said earlier, the chances of us hitting the right one so early is remote, we're helping hte wolves.

As numbers thin we have two advantages:
1 - We might have picked up on a pattern.
2- If we lynch blindly our chances of hitting the wolf by chance alone are statistically improved.

Only the wolves can gain from early lynchings.

But I wanna lynch Parsifal 

If we kill one of our own, it lowers the amount needed for a consensus vote, thus making me not have to listen to al this blah blah blah lets not kill anyone crap.

If we kill one of our own, it lowers the amount needed for a consensus vote, thus making me not have to listen to al this blah blah blah lets not kill anyone crap.

So, you don't care that statistically it's more helpful to the wolves? Sounds like you have a bloodlust to me... Could Dann be the Wolf?

Besides, Parsifal is so keen on no lynching, just like a wolf would be

Wait before we start lynching. As somebody said earlier, the chances of us hitting the right one so early is remote, we're helping hte wolves.

As numbers thin we have two advantages:
1 - We might have picked up on a pattern.
2- If we lynch blindly our chances of hitting the wolf by chance alone are statistically improved.

Only the wolves can gain from early lynchings.

That's what I've been trying to tell people for the last three pages.

Besides, Parsifal is so keen on no lynching, just like a wolf would be

If early lynching helps wolves (and it would), then why would a wolf be keen on no lynching?

Quote from: Colonel Gaydafi on January 08, 2010, 03:09:38 AM

Besides, Parsifal is so keen on no lynching, just like a wolf would be

If early lynching helps wolves (and it would), then why would a wolf be keen on no lynching?

Cos you're a wolf and you don't wanna be lynched. (and so far most of the votes are for you)

Quote from: theonlydann on January 08, 2010, 03:05:27 AM

If we kill one of our own, it lowers the amount needed for a consensus vote, thus making me not have to listen to al this blah blah blah lets not kill anyone crap.

So, you don't care that statistically it's more helpful to the wolves? Sounds like you have a bloodlust to me... Could Dann be the Wolf?

I could be. Or i could be a pissed off villager who is pissed at the local government for not supporting my original ban on wolves as pets, so now, since i have lost three sheep, two cows and my puppies favorite chew toy (although Lolly could have buried it) i just want so DAMNED ANSWERS AND WANNA SEE SOMEONE HANG!

Quote from: Mrs. Peach on January 07, 2010, 11:22:55 PM

I think I'll just wait till a bandwagon gets rolling and jump on.  Yup, mob mentality for me.

Same here, just to get the kill. It seems Parsifal has the highest amount of votes so far. Hmm...

I have to say... knowing Steves whiny depressed personality...

and that two people have voted for him...

Someone knows he isn't a wolf.

Cos you're a wolf and you don't wanna be lynched. (and so far most of the votes are for you)

And of course, if I was a villager I would be perfectly happy to let my fellow villagers snuff the life out of me. That makes perfect sense.

Quote from: Colonel Gaydafi on January 08, 2010, 03:14:45 AM

Cos you're a wolf and you don't wanna be lynched. (and so far most of the votes are for you)

And of course, if I was a villager I would be perfectly happy to let my fellow villagers snuff the life out of me. That makes perfect sense.

Well if you were drunk you probably would want to be lynched

Quote from: Parsifal on January 08, 2010, 03:41:29 AM

Quote from: Colonel Gaydafi on January 08, 2010, 03:14:45 AM

Cos you're a wolf and you don't wanna be lynched. (and so far most of the votes are for you)

And of course, if I was a villager I would be perfectly happy to let my fellow villagers snuff the life out of me. That makes perfect sense.

Well if you were drunk you probably would want to be lynched

STEVE IS BEING SET UP BY THE CONSPIRACY AND THE ANTI-FUR MOVEMENT!

Quote from: Chris Spaghetti on January 08, 2010, 03:09:18 AM

Quote from: theonlydann on January 08, 2010, 03:05:27 AM

If we kill one of our own, it lowers the amount needed for a consensus vote, thus making me not have to listen to al this blah blah blah lets not kill anyone crap.

So, you don't care that statistically it's more helpful to the wolves? Sounds like you have a bloodlust to me... Could Dann be the Wolf?

I could be. Or i could be a pissed off villager who is pissed at the local government for not supporting my original ban on wolves as pets, so now, since i have lost three sheep, two cows and my puppies favorite chew toy (although Lolly could have buried it) i just want so DAMNED ANSWERS AND WANNA SEE SOMEONE HANG!

Ah ha! you've just admitted you have had a puppy! The evidence is mounting, Dann!

Now shut up and vote for someone to die.

No way, wolfman!

I've got my eye on you (and if I die tonight we can be reasonably sure who one wolf is!)

No way, wolfman!

I've got my eye on you (and if I die tonight we can be reasonably sure who one wolf is!)

AH! Chris is the wolf and he is trying to set me up by sacrificing himself! LYNCH HIS ASS!

(i am not voting for chris to die, as i love him.)

Wait, what's going on? People are saying BanthaPoodoo is dead and that it's now day, but the OP isn't updated for me. It still shows everyone as alive and that it's still night.

WTF?

EDIT: Whoops hehe, didn't even notice Wilmore ended the night already in page 4. But this is useful information; the time between posting this thread and when the night ended was mere seven hours. So anyone who weren't online during that time cannot be wolf Shatner. Who wants to do investigation?

Either way, this just increases my suspicion for Sean. The way he started the lynch voting, too, seems a little odd. So I vote to lynch Sean. And I suggest you do the same, or there won't be a lynch at all.

True Blanko. True. But he posted something a page or two back that said it is LYNCHING TIME!

So it is Day... but OP fucked up.

I forgot about the editing rule, so for clarification: I vote to lynch Sean.