if earth is flat are all the other planets flat?

so if eath is flat are all the other planets flat ??

Planets are spherical http://theflatearthsociety.org/forum/index.php?topic=19905.0. From what I have seen, many FE'ers think planets are spherical but that the Earth is somehow special http://theflatearthsociety.org/forum/index.php?topic=19761.0.

Mars is flat too (see sig link)

so al other planets are round and earth isn't HOW the hell dose that work why is earth the only flat one?

so al other planets are round and earth isn't HOW the hell dose that work why is earth the only flat one?

Quite simply, because the Earth isn't the other planets.  It's an assumption to say that earth is a planet like what you see in the sky.

(this is the FE argument, I believe)

well if earth isnt a planet then what is it ?

It's the Earth. 

Welcome to the Flat Earth. 

well if earth isnt a planet then what is it ?

The earth is an infinite plane which cuts the universe in half. The earth is not a celestial body. The earth is the only known material world and the only environment known to support life. The earth is our Terra Firma.

Quote from: ROUND!! on February 17, 2008, 09:28:48 PM

well if earth isnt a planet then what is it ?

The earth is an infinite plane which cuts the universe in half. The earth is not a celestial body. The earth is the only known material world and the only environment known to support life. The earth is our Terra Firma.

The opposite of what he said.

If the infinite plane earth cuts the universe in half, how can there be another half if it keeps moving in the same direction? The half below the earth will always be getting bigger and the half above getting smaller. Hardly halves if you asked me!!!

The infinite earth is not moving.

Just wanted to point out that that is completely inconceivable. There must be some movement, even if it were but one joule of energy...but then, there are no rigid bodies allowed in Einsteinian physics, so the Earth can't really be flat and infinite unless there is no movement...strange paradox, that.

then how is mars flat 2 is it also a celestial body??

It's a flat celestial body.  But they're very rare.

Just wanted to point out that that is completely inconceivable. There must be some movement, even if it were but one joule of energy...but then, there are no rigid bodies allowed in Einsteinian physics, so the Earth can't really be flat and infinite unless there is no movement...strange paradox, that.

I'm pretty sure the term rigid body assumes it is finite.

if its so rare why can  see it when i walk outside at night?? is it on the same "plane" as earth in the midde not moving

What makes these celestial bodies different from the others that makes them flat and not spherical like the others? There is proof that anyone can see with there own eyes that the moon, Mars and Jupiter are round. (not using the crazy infinite Earth theory)

What makes these celestial bodies different from the others that makes them flat and not spherical like the others? There is proof that anyone can see with there own eyes that the moon, Mars and Jupiter are round. (not using the crazy infinite Earth theory)

Lies. Illusions cooked up by the conspiracy.

There is nothing crazy about an infinite earth.

Quote from: fshy94 on February 19, 2008, 07:24:50 PM

Just wanted to point out that that is completely inconceivable. There must be some movement, even if it were but one joule of energy...but then, there are no rigid bodies allowed in Einsteinian physics, so the Earth can't really be flat and infinite unless there is no movement...strange paradox, that.

I'm pretty sure the term rigid body assumes it is finite.

So then, its really a parabolic shape then, no? If its not rigid, then any movement whatsoever will make the Earth parabolic, not flat, right?

so if there is no move ment and no gravity what keeps me from floating away??

Right...the conspiracy causes your own eyes to see the Moon wobble in its orbit (lunar libration) and the details on Mars to disappear around the other side of the planet through a telescope over time, same with the great red spot of Jupiter... (can someone tell me what the "eye rolling" smilies command is? its broken for me...)

so if there is no move ment and no gravity what keeps me from floating away??

God. He's constantly keeping you on the earth through intelligent falling.

[qupte]Right...the conspiracy causes your own eyes to see the Moon wobble in its orbit (lunar libration) and the details on Mars to disappear around the other side of the planet through a telescope over time, same with the great red spot of Jupiter... (can someone tell me what the "eye rolling" smilies command is? its broken for me...)[/quote]

I have said before, the planets are merely projected onto the ionosphere by the conspiracy. They can make you see anything they want.

right...i do hope your being sarcastic

wow waht do you know just saying its a conspiracy... what a great answer you got there

Quote from: Username on February 20, 2008, 05:03:08 AM

Quote from: fshy94 on February 19, 2008, 07:24:50 PM

Just wanted to point out that that is completely inconceivable. There must be some movement, even if it were but one joule of energy...but then, there are no rigid bodies allowed in Einsteinian physics, so the Earth can't really be flat and infinite unless there is no movement...strange paradox, that.

I'm pretty sure the term rigid body assumes it is finite.

So then, its really a parabolic shape then, no? If its not rigid, then any movement whatsoever will make the Earth parabolic, not flat, right?

Rigid is a term that describes finite bodies.

Anyways, I'm sure its moving some, you are right.   Its just not noticable.

wow waht do you know just saying its a conspiracy... what a great answer you got there

ROUND!!, Read the FAQ

ROUND!! has a point though. Anything FE can't explain they have to resort to "tis the conspiracy!" despite how illogical some of the stuff is.

No, not really.

Quote from: ROUND!! on February 20, 2008, 11:42:36 AM

so if there is no move ment and no gravity what keeps me from floating away??

God. He's constantly keeping you on the earth through intelligent falling.

Quote

Right...the conspiracy causes your own eyes to see the Moon wobble in its orbit (lunar libration) and the details on Mars to disappear around the other side of the planet through a telescope over time, same with the great red spot of Jupiter... (can someone tell me what the "eye rolling" smilies command is? its broken for me...)

I have said before, the planets are merely projected onto the ionosphere by the conspiracy. They can make you see anything they want.

Oops. Meant to modify it.

Come on! Holograms in the ionosphere? Either thats the stupidest thing I have ever heard or its sarcasm.