Sigh. How many times do I have to say "focus"? It's bad enough that the FEers tend to distract us from the main point in these debates; we don't need the REers doing it too. Tom never said that the zetetic method doesn't involve making a hypothesis before performing an experiment, and you know it. If he comes in and says that directly, then attack that point. Until then, please, let's not derail this discussion.
I ask, again, if anybody has a relevant portion on Garwood's book about Wallace's experiment, or, for that matter, any other reproduction of Rowbotham's experiments. I don't think Tom should be able to win his line of argument simply by citing a source that's unavailable to me at the moment.
- Kef