I was showing how a finite earth could work without the atmosphere leaking away.
The air would be lost from what I can tell. In the same way if you make a tower of water and let it go, the water will spread apart, and if the outsides were so cold that they were to make the water frozen, the warmer water in the centre will still have some force to it and push the frozen water out further.
@New Earth, stick around till after December '12 so I can rub it in, please
