Werepenguins - The Perth Massacre

Ok, the simplest quetsion is probably going to be: do we want to go after active players and judge them for that, or quieter players that might be trying to slip under the radar?

On a purely meta level I like the idea of eliminating the people who don't contribute.  Makes the end game spicier.

Where is Bullwinkle anyway? Or should I say, were?

I am so confused I think you're all penguins at this point. 

I vote to lynch Pez.

I will vote with you, however, who is the most suspicious at this point? I am thinking Jane, but I am not sure. 

Jane is my top, but I voted Pez since he game been active much this day cycle.

I dunno...Jane feels more likely to me than Pezevenk, but it may just be because she's one of the most involved.

Jroa's behavior suggests one of two things...he's either a penguin, or he is inexplicably working in their favor by basically just throwing everything into confusion.

Cowgirl also seems fishy with this "roasting marshmallow" business.  I'm leaning in these directions...waiting to hear more opinions...

I'm leaning Space Cowgirl but I'm not all confident in that.

I will vote SCG, but I would like to know first what makes you suspect her?  I would also vote for Jane, or any of you f*ckers.  Pez is as good of a pick as any one else, and so am I.  Let us not forget Cruton from the last round.  And that boydster guy is still very suspicious as well. 

I will vote SCG, but I would like to know first what makes you suspect her?  I would also vote for Jane, or any of you f*ckers.  Pez is as good of a pick as any one else, and so am I.  Let us not forget Cruton from the last round.  And that boydster guy is still very suspicious as well.

It's partly intuition, which I admit is lousy.  Also I feel that we're better off voting to lynch more than one person as the conflict will give us more information.

Crouton did act extremely suspiciously that last round of werepenguin.  It's like he knew what role every had but he let the penguins win anyways.  Clearly working for the penguins.

Crouton did act extremely suspiciously that last round of werepenguin. 

I agree.

The moose is also suspiciously quiet.  Hmmmm

I have to stand by Roundy, Crouton, SCG, Bullwinkle, Pez and jroa as at least one of them definitely being a penguin.

Got to disagree. You missed a few suspects. I think it's one of the following:
Crouton
Space Cowgirl
Jane
Bullwinkle
DuckDodgers
Pezevenk
Jura-Glenlivet II
deadsirius
jroa
Roundy the Truthinessist

Also:
[I vote to lynch Space Cowgirl]

I have to vote someone because DD just voted for me and I don't want to risk dying, someone already voted SCG and SCG is acting exactly like the last game.

[I vote to lynch DuckDodgers]

I DON'T KNOW WHO TO VOTE FOR!

Uh, I thought Jroa already voted for SCG?

Quote from: Jane on July 30, 2018, 10:24:11 AM

I have to stand by Roundy, Crouton, SCG, Bullwinkle, Pez and jroa as at least one of them definitely being a penguin.

Got to disagree. You missed a few suspects.

One of the penguins must have voted for Shifter.

Well, if this is turning into chaos: I vote to lynch Bullwinkle
Just because round one he was staying out of sight, and round two he's just being bizarre. SCG is the only one that seems to have even slightly suspected Ducky, and then deadsirius thought he might be the truthterra so that vote is out of nowhere.

Wait, I thought Jroa already voted for SCG?

I said I will do that if someone gives me a reason to do so.  Nobody has given a reason to vote for anyone yet. 

Quote from: Pezevenk on July 30, 2018, 11:57:10 AM

Wait, I thought Jroa already voted for SCG?

I said I will do that if someone gives me a reason to do so.  Nobody has given a reason to vote for anyone yet.

It sort of makes sense to do that on one hand, but on the other hand, no one really knows anything about anyone and no one has a good reason to vote for anyone.

Quote from: Pezevenk on July 30, 2018, 11:43:20 AM

Quote from: Jane on July 30, 2018, 10:24:11 AM

I have to stand by Roundy, Crouton, SCG, Bullwinkle, Pez and jroa as at least one of them definitely being a penguin.

Got to disagree. You missed a few suspects.

One of the penguins must have voted for Shifter.

Not really, why?

Quote from: jroa on July 30, 2018, 12:04:57 PM

Quote from: Pezevenk on July 30, 2018, 11:57:10 AM

Wait, I thought Jroa already voted for SCG?

I said I will do that if someone gives me a reason to do so.  Nobody has given a reason to vote for anyone yet.

It sort of makes sense to do that on one hand, but on the other hand, no one really knows anything about anyone and no one has a good reason to vote for anyone.

Then, why were you so quick to vote for SCG?  Suspicious... 

Quote from: Pezevenk on July 30, 2018, 12:07:28 PM

Quote from: jroa on July 30, 2018, 12:04:57 PM

Quote from: Pezevenk on July 30, 2018, 11:57:10 AM

Wait, I thought Jroa already voted for SCG?

I said I will do that if someone gives me a reason to do so.  Nobody has given a reason to vote for anyone yet.

It sort of makes sense to do that on one hand, but on the other hand, no one really knows anything about anyone and no one has a good reason to vote for anyone.

Then, why were you so quick to vote for SCG?  Suspicious...

Because someone voted for me and I got scared so I had to vote someone. I thought you had already voted SCG so I voted her to ensure I wouldn't end up dead lol. SCG is my best bet so far anyways.

Well, we have less than 4 hours to go, if boydster sticks to the 7:00 PM EDT that he has not been sticking to.  So, for all we know, our vote is over in 30 minutes.  I don't know who to vote for.  I am not suspicious of SCG.  I am a little suspicious of Jane.  Also, I don't know about Cruton or Pez.  I will vote for whomever the rest of you want to lynch, but I do have my eyeball on DD and Roundy.  Fuck, you are all suspicious.

I am going to cast my vote for DD if we don't get some kind of consensus or a majority.  He is suspiciously quiet. 

Quote from: Jane on July 30, 2018, 11:59:02 AM

Quote from: Pezevenk on July 30, 2018, 11:43:20 AM

Quote from: Jane on July 30, 2018, 10:24:11 AM

I have to stand by Roundy, Crouton, SCG, Bullwinkle, Pez and jroa as at least one of them definitely being a penguin.

Got to disagree. You missed a few suspects.

One of the penguins must have voted for Shifter.

Why?

He's an innocent, they'd wanted to have been sure he was killed, especially when there was already a voice against him so it didn't seem suspicious.
That's part of why I'm suspicious of Roundy. Shifter did nothing he didn't do last game when we knew he was innocent, he wasn't suspicious at all. Starting the voting train that killed our exorcist is suspicious, and the same goes for Bullwinkle. Possibly SCG, though I'm used to distracting attention from her so I am biased on that count.

What is the vote now?  1 for Pez and 1 for SCG, or do I need to read the last page again?

What is the vote now?  1 for Pez and 1 for SCG, or do I need to read the last page again?

One for Pez, SCG, Ducky and Bullwinkle.

Quote from: Pezevenk on July 30, 2018, 12:09:19 PM

Quote from: Jane on July 30, 2018, 11:59:02 AM

Quote from: Pezevenk on July 30, 2018, 11:43:20 AM

Quote from: Jane on July 30, 2018, 10:24:11 AM

I have to stand by Roundy, Crouton, SCG, Bullwinkle, Pez and jroa as at least one of them definitely being a penguin.

Got to disagree. You missed a few suspects.

One of the penguins must have voted for Shifter.

Why?

He's an innocent, they'd wanted to have been sure he was killed, especially when there was already a voice against him so it didn't seem suspicious.
That's part of why I'm suspicious of Roundy. Shifter did nothing he didn't do last game when we knew he was innocent, he wasn't suspicious at all. Starting the voting train that killed our exorcist is suspicious, and the same goes for Bullwinkle. Possibly SCG, though I'm used to distracting attention from her so I am biased on that count.

That's dumb. Shifter was going down anyways after the first couple votes, it was obvious. Why would a penguin bring attention on itself by voting for someone who'd die anyways? Maybe you knew that and that's why you voted for someone else 

I don't know. I have no clue what I'm talking about.

Quote from: jroa on July 30, 2018, 12:27:00 PM

What is the vote now?  1 for Pez and 1 for SCG, or do I need to read the last page again?

One for Pez, SCG, Ducky and Bullwinkle.

if this is true, then it seems I have a deciding vote.  I have power!

That's dumb. Shifter was going down anyways after the first couple votes, it was obvious. Why would a penguin bring attention on itself by voting for someone who'd die anyways? Maybe you knew that and that's why you voted for someone else 

I don't know. I have no clue what I'm talking about.

Because there were twelve of us and no way to know whether a majority would vote. It's how it was in the last game too; I voted each and every time, and I'm pretty sure SCG did for most, at least.
I'm well aware that being the one to point out this tactic does make it look like I'm abusing it, but remember I was a penguin, I know how the role makes you think. It clearly didn't bring attention to them because no one mentioned it.

At least one, maybe two of the people on that list is a penguin. I'm certain of that, mark my words.

Quote from: Jane on July 30, 2018, 12:29:00 PM

Quote from: jroa on July 30, 2018, 12:27:00 PM

What is the vote now?  1 for Pez and 1 for SCG, or do I need to read the last page again?

One for Pez, SCG, Ducky and Bullwinkle.

if this is true, then it seems I have a deciding vote.  I have power!

You could vote for Boydster.

Bugger! How long before the end of voting?